During a recent episode of the Heretic Happy Hour podcast, I, along with Keith Giles, Desimber Rose, Eve_wasframed, and John Fugelsang, shed some light on the complex and often contentious intersection of politics and the Bible in modern American society. This panel discussion, anchored in recent Pew Research findings, delves into the implications of intertwining religious values with legislative processes, and critically examines how contemporary interpretations of Christian values align (or rather, misalign) with the teachings of Jesus Christ.
The Contemporary Christian Landscape
I kick off the discussion by citing a Pew Research article that reveals how many Americans believe the federal government should promote Christian values, and that the Bible should influence U.S. laws. This finding is significant in understanding the current socio-political climate where religion and governance frequently intersect (to great detriment). It raises questions about the nature of these so-called “Christian values” and their alignment with the foundational teachings of Jesus.
Fugelsang makes a critical distinction between “Christian values” and the values directly taught by Christ. He argues that many things labeled as Christian today, such as opposition to abortion and LGBTQ+ rights, do not necessarily reflect the teachings of Jesus. Instead, Jesus emphasized compassion, care for the marginalized, and social justice–principles that seem to be overshadowed by modern political agendas. This discrepancy highlights a crucial aspect of the discussion: the difference between cultural Christianity and the radical inclusiveness taught by Jesus.
Symbolism Versus Substance
A significant portion of the conversation revolves around the use of Jesus as a political symbol. Fugelsang criticizes how Jesus is often co-opted as a mascot for political causes that may not reflect his teachings. This sentiment is echoed by Desimber Rose, who observes that the political deployment of Christian symbolism often excludes the very principles Jesus championed, such as welcoming strangers and caring for the needy. This manipulation of religious symbols for political ends raises ethical concerns about authenticity and integrity in political discourse.
As a post-Christian, yet one who is also appreciative of the historical Jesus, I further complicate the narrative. I personally view Jesus through a humanist lens, emphasizing his teachings on social justice, as seen in his first sermon in Luke 4. I suggest that a true adherence to these teachings would focus on systemic changes like debt forgiveness and support for the oppressed, rather than punitive legislative measures. This perspective invites a reevaluation of what it means to follow Jesus in a modern context.
Fundamentalism and Its Dangers
Later in the show, we analyze the rise of religious fundamentalism and its implications for both religious and secular societies. Fugelsang points out that extreme conservative Christians often share fundamentalist traits with extreme religious groups of other faiths, such as the subjugation of women and hostility towards LGBTQ+ individuals. This alignment is problematic as it diverges sharply from the inclusive and compassionate message of Jesus.
Keith Giles agrees, noting that the term “Christian” has diverged significantly from “Christ-like” behavior. He underscores the importance of returning to the core teachings of Jesus, which advocate for love, compassion, and social justice. This return to foundational Christian principles is crucial in countering the negative impacts of fundamentalism and promoting a more inclusive and just society.
Political Manifestations
On the episode, we also explore how these religious dynamics manifest in contemporary politics. We discuss laws in states like Arizona, which reflect a blend of state and religious values, often regressive in nature. Desimber highlights the dangers of such laws, arguing that they seek to recreate a society that privileges a narrow group, often at the expense of others’ rights and freedoms. This critique aligns with the broader theme of how Christian values are manipulated to support conservative political agendas, rather than promoting the inclusive and compassionate values of Jesus.
The Need for Separation of Church and State
A recurring theme in the discussion is the need for a clear separation between church and state. We continue to argue that while personal faith can inform individual values, the imposition of specific religious values on the broader population can lead to exclusion and injustice. We advocate for a political system that respects diverse beliefs while ensuring that laws and policies are just and inclusive.
I would go on to cite another Pew Research survey showing that a majority of Americans believe religion is losing influence in public life, with many viewing this as a negative development. This finding underscores the tension between secular and religious perspectives in American society. Later, we suggest that addressing this tension requires a balanced approach that respects both religious freedoms and secular principles.
Conclusion
In this episode, our panel discussion provides a critical examination of how Christian values are interpreted and applied in contemporary politics. It emphasizes the need to distinguish between the historical teachings of Jesus and the political agendas that often invoke his name. By returning to the core principles of compassion, inclusiveness, and social justice taught by Jesus, there is potential to create a more just and equitable society. This dialogue is a call to critically evaluate the role of religion in politics and to strive for a political system that truly embodies the teachings of one of history’s most influential figures.
Check out the Heretic Happy Hour podcast wherever you listen to podcasts: Spotify, iTunes.
Also, if you’ve been digging my work on here, and want to see me be able to continue writing as close to full-time as humanly possible, please take a look at my Patreon page at www.patreon.com/mjdistefano. Even $1 a month helps bigly!
Ad-Free & Subscriber Log-In